Standard of Care in Health Care Law

Doctors working on a patient and practicing good standard of care.

What is the Standard of Care in a Medical Malpractice or Negligence Lawsuit? Our National Healthcare Attorneys Explain

Medical malpractice or professional negligence claims focus on two closely related legal concepts:

    1. Did the defendant owe a duty to the plaintiff?
    2. Did the defendant breach the duty owed?

The plaintiff is the person bringing the lawsuit and defendant is the health care provider. The very first inquiry in all medical malpractice defense claims is whether the defendant owed a duty to the plaintiff. The issue centers on the question of whether a health care provider/patient relationship was established.

To establish a health care provider/patient relationship:

    1. The defendant must first be licensed under the state public health code;
    2. The defendant must be engaged in providing professional services to the plaintiff; and 
    3. The alleged harm must have occurred during the professional relationship and naturally flow from the relationship.

Is There an Example of Standard of Care That Doesn’t Involve Medical Malpractice/Negligence?

The best way to explain this is to think of a neighborhood with grass lawns. Some neighbors have meticulously manicured lawns with every blade of grass trimmed to perfection. Some neighbors simply cut their lawns every week to prevent overgrowth. Finally, some neighbors let their lawn grow out of control and never cut it.

If you were to drive through the neighborhood you would conclude that some of the neighbors deserve an A, some a B or C, and some a D or E for effort. Those receiving a D or E fall below the standard of care. Those with a C represent the average, and the A’s or B’s represent care above the standard.

Following the same analogy, the A thru C homeowners did not breach the standard of care, while the D and E homeowners breached the standard of care because their lawns fell below the neighborhood standard.

If a lawyer were to take this matter to trial, the jury would more likely than not conclude the homeowner with a D or E fell below the standard of care and, therefore, would be liable for all damages proximately caused.

How Do You Determine What the Standard of Care Actually Is?

Generally, standard of care is established with expert testimony. The expert generally must testify that he/she is similarly trained, board-certified in the same field, etc., and that based on his/her experience and training, the standard of care required the health care provider to do or not do something.

How Does a Jury Make a Determination on Standard of Care?

Assuming all the factors establish a health care provider/patient relationship, the issue centers on the standard of care. More precisely, the jury question is whether the health care provider breached the standard of care.

The actual jury instruction generally reads like this: “Did the health care provider provide treatment that was equal to or greater than what an average health care provider would provide under the same or similar circumstances?” This is known as a reasonableness standard.

The physician or nurse or other health care provider is not required to be any more competent than the average health care provider with the same or similar training would be under the same or similar circumstances.

How Can the National Medical Malpractice Defense Lawyers at Chapman Law Group Help My Healthcare Practice?

While medical malpractice defense is one of the most difficult litigation challenges for an attorney, we at Chapman Law Group have successfully defended hundreds of complicated medical malpractice claims with exceptional results. We understand the complexities of health care and work hard to defend your good name.

For 35 years running, Chapman Law Group is the No. 1 choice for medical malpractice, professional liability, and negligence claims throughout the nation. Our lawyers have a portfolio of successful representation for physiciansuninsured healthcare providers (in Florida and other states that apply),  dentists, pain management specialists, and many other licensed healthcare professionals 

We are a national healthcare defense practice, with four offices: Detroit, MichiganMiami and Sarasota, Florida; and Los Angeles/Southern California. Contact us today for more information.

Need an Attorney? Contact us now!
or Call us at: 1 (877) 234-5911

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Got A Question?

Contact me now to schedule a consultation.

Other Practice Areas​

Professional Liability/
Malpractice Defense

Related Case Results

Related Blog Posts

Protecting Your Rights Against Sham Peer Review

If you are confronted with a challenge to your hospital staff privileges or by a potential adverse hospital credentialing matter, the professional licensing and regulatory affairs attorneys at Chapman Law Group are here for you.

Read More »

FREE Health Care Newsletter

Stay up to date on the latest news in health care law!
Chapman Law Group Favicon

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.

Send this to a friend