Protecting Your Rights Against Sham Peer Review

A suspension or revocation of medical staff privileges is one of the most harrowing experiences a physician can imagine. The damage from an adverse determination by a hospital’s formal hearing panel can be devastating. You can face the short-term effects of the inability to practice at the related facility, but also there is potential for related peer review actions by other credentialed entities including, reporting to the National Practitioner Data Bank (NPDB), reporting to and potential sanctions from medical board certification organizations, public and private insurance carriers, professional liability carriers and state boards of medicine. For these reasons you should contact a health care defense attorney with experience in addressing issues related to physician peer reviews.

Sham Peer Review Defense

The cornerstone of the defense of a physician under medical peer review will be to challenge the hospital’s conformance to the requirements of the Health Care Quality Improvement Act of 1986 (HCQIA) and the institution’s bylaws. It is imperative to begin to build an effective defense as soon as possible given the short timeframes for requesting a fair hearing, obtaining and reviewing relevant medical records and documentary evidence and obtaining expert witness support.

A checklist of critical information to compile as soon as possible in any potential physician peer review case includes the following:

      1. Your C.V.
      2. Any documents related to prior peer review or disciplinary matters
      3. Any communications, including emails and/or text messages, with hospital administration or fellow staff members
      4. A timeline of events leading to the incident(s) resulting in sham peer review
      5. A list of any prior criminal convictions, licensing sanctions or investigations and professional liability claims

If you are confronted with a challenge to your hospital staff privileges or by a potential adverse hospital credentialing matter, contact Aaron Kemp, Senior Attorney and Chairperson of the Professional Licensing & Regulatory Affairs Group at Chapman Law Group, for representation.

Need an Attorney? Contact us now!


  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Attorney

Aaron J. Kemp

Senior Attorney

Chairperson of Professional Licensing & Regulatory Affairs

Michigan Office
1441 West Long Lake Rd., Ste. 310
Troy, MI 48098
Phone: (248) 644-6326

Recent Posts

Blog Categories

Blog Archives

Related Practice Areas

Related Posts

Got A Question?

Call now to schedule a consultation.

Send this to a friend