The Risk of Unauthorized Medical Record Access White Paper 2026
Laith Quasem, addresses a risk that is often a routine decision: opening a patient’s electronic medical record without a legitimate reason….
For physicians and other healthcare providers, losing Medicare billing privileges can be professionally and financially devastating. A revocation can prevent a provider from receiving Medicare reimbursement, jeopardize employment, and disrupt an otherwise successful medical career. In some cases, these consequences take effect long before the provider has an opportunity to challenge the revocation before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ).
Under the current Medicare appeals process, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) does not provide an evidentiary hearing before revoking a provider’s billing privileges. Instead, CMS, generally through its relevant Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC), issues a revocation notice, and the provider must challenge that decision through an administrative appeals process that can take months or even years to complete.
A recent decision from the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit raises an important constitutional question: Must CMS provide a healthcare provider with a meaningful hearing before imposing sanctions that threaten the provider’s livelihood?
In Lee v. Kennedy, No. 26-1820 (9th Cir. Sept. 15, 2026), the Ninth Circuit reversed a federal district court’s dismissal of a physician’s due process claim, allowing him to pursue his constitutional challenge without first completing the Medicare administrative appeals process. Although the decision does not establish an automatic right to hearing before every Medicare revocation, it represents a potentially important development for providers challenging CMS enforcement actions.
Dr. Mansur Lee is a board-certified physician in internal medicine and hospice and palliative medicine. From July 2019 through March 2025, he served as the medical director of Passion and Love Hospice while also working as a hospitalist at Providence St. Jude Medical Center. In March 2025, CMS revoked the hospice’s Medicare billing privileges after determining that it had submitted reimbursement claims without adequate documentation supporting patients’ terminal illness prognoses.
Approximately two months later, CMS revoked Dr. Lee’s individual Medicare billing privileges based on his affiliation with the hospice. CMS determined that his role as medical director constituted an affiliation posing an “undue risk of fraud, waste, or abuse” to the Medicare program under 42 C.F.R. § 424.535(a)(19). CMS also imposed a 10-year re-enrollment bar and placed Dr. Lee on the publicly accessible CMS Preclusion List, which restricts payment for certain services furnished to Medicare Advantage beneficiaries.
To reiterate, CMS effectively barred Dr. Lee from Medicare for ten years based on his affiliation with the hospice, without necessarily identifying any independent finding that he personally submitted fraudulent claims or engaged in improper billing conduct. Indeed, 42 C.F.R. § 424.535(a)(19), as written, does not require CMS to establish that a provider personally engaged in fraud or improper billing to revoke the provider’s Medicare enrollment based on an affiliation deemed to pose an undue risk of fraud, waste, or abuse.
The consequences extended well beyond his work with that organization. According to the decision, Dr. Lee lost his separate hospitalist position at St. Jude as a result of the sanctions. Dr. Lee requested reconsideration of CMS’s determination, but CMS upheld the revocation. He subsequently filed suit in the federal district court, arguing, among other things, that the Constitution required a hearing before CMS imposed the sanctions. At the time, the administrative appeal remained pending before an ALJ. The district court dismissed the lawsuit because he had not completed the administrative appeals process. Dr. Lee appealed that dismissal to the Ninth Circuit.
To understand why Lee v. Kennedy is significant, it is important to understand how Medicare revocations currently work. CMS does not ordinarily provide a physician or other healthcare provider with an evidentiary hearing before issuing a revocation. Instead, the process begins with a written revocation notice, generally issued through the relevant Medicare contractor, informing the provider of CMS’s determination, the grounds for revocation, and the applicable sanctions. The provider may then submit a written request for reconsideration, explaining why the revocation should be overturned and providing supporting evidence.
However, reconsideration is generally a paper-based review, not an evidentiary hearing. The provider does not have the same opportunity to present live testimony and challenge evidence that may be available during a subsequent ALJ proceeding. Moreover, CMS can take months to issue a reconsidered determination, leaving providers waiting for a decision while their ability to bill Medicare, maintain employment, and participate in Medicare-dependent healthcare arrangements may already be severely compromised. Although the effective date of a revocation depends on the regulatory grounds involved, filing a reconsideration request generally does not automatically suspend the revocation or restore the provider’s billing privileges.
If CMS ultimately upholds the revocation, the provider may then request a hearing before an ALJ. An unfavorable ALJ decision may be appealed to the Departmental Appeals Board, followed by judicial review in federal court. By the time a provider receives an opportunity for an evidentiary hearing, months may have passed since the initial revocation. Completing the entire administrative appeals process can take considerably longer. During this time, a physician may lose employment, a healthcare business may lose substantial revenue, and a provider’s professional reputation may suffer lasting damage. Even if the provider ultimately prevails, the financial losses and professional disruption may be difficult or impossible to reverse.
This creates a fundamental due process concern: What good is a hearing if the provider has already suffered irreparable professional harm before that hearing occurs? That question lies at the heart of Lee v. Kennedy.
The Ninth Circuit drew an important distinction between challenging the substance of a Medicare revocation and challenging the constitutional adequacy of the procedures used to impose it. Dr. Lee raised two separate claims.
First, he argued that CMS had exceeded its legal authority by imposing the sanctions. The Ninth Circuit agreed with the district court that this claim could not proceed before Dr. Lee exhausted his administrative remedies. Second, Dr. Lee argued that he was constitutionally entitled to a hearing before CMS imposed the sanctions. On this issue, the Ninth Circuit reached a different conclusion.
Relying on Mathews v. Eldridge, 424 U.S. 319 (1976), and other federal decisions addressing administrative exhaustion, the court determined that Dr. Lee’s due process claim could proceed independently of his underlying challenge to the revocation. The court emphasized three considerations:
Accordingly, the Ninth Circuit reversed the dismissal of Dr. Lee’s due process claim and remanded the case to the district court for further proceedings. The court also denied Dr. Lee’s pending request for injunctive relief without prejudice, allowing him to raise the request again on remand.
Not necessarily. At least, not yet. The Ninth Circuit did not decide whether the Constitution ultimately required CMS to provide Dr. Lee with a pre-deprivation hearing. Instead, the court held that his constitutional claim could be heard by a federal district court without waiting for the completion of the administrative appeals process.
Under Matthews v. Eldridge, courts evaluating what procedural protections are constitutionally required generally consider three factors:
For Medicare-enrolled providers, these considerations can be particularly significant. A revocation may deprive a physician of an important source of income, prevent participation in Medicare-related healthcare arrangements, and threaten employment opportunities. At the same time, CMS has a substantial interest in protecting Medicare beneficiaries and safeguarding federal healthcare funds from fraud, waste, and abuse. The question is whether existing procedures adequately balance those competing interests, particularly when the sanctions take effect before the provider received an evidentiary hearing. The district court will have an opportunity to consider that constitutional question on remand.
The potential implications of Lee v. Kennedy extend beyond the individual physician involved.
First, the decision recognizes that Medicare revocation can cause harm that cannot simply be remedied through the ordinary appeals process. CMS revocations are not merely administrative inconveniences. For some providers, they can mean the loss of employment, substantial income, and professional opportunities. The Ninth Circuit expressly recognized the significance of Dr. Lee’s loss of employment when evaluating whether he had suffered irreparable injury.
Second, the decision identifies a potential avenue for earlier federal court review of certain constitutional challenges. Ordinarily, providers must work through the Medicare administrative appeals process before seeking judicial review. Under the reasoning applied in Lee, however, a provider asserting a sufficiently distinct pre-deprivation due process claim may be able to pursue that claim in federal court before exhausting administrative remedies. This does not mean every provider can bypass the administrative process simply by alleging a constitutional violation. The nature of the claim, the harm suffered, and the purpose of further administrative proceedings remain important considerations.
Third, the decision may be particularly relevant to revocations based on allegedly problematic affiliations. Under 42 C.F.R. § 424.535(a)(19), CMS may revoke Medicare enrollment when it determines that a provider has an affiliation with another entity or individual that poses an undue risk of fraud, waste, or abuse. These determinations can be especially consequential for physicians who have served as medical directors, owners, managing employees, or in other professional capacities at organizations that subsequently experience Medicare enforcement actions. As Dr. Lee’s case illustrates, the consequences of an affiliation-based revocation can extend far beyond the organization that originally came under scrutiny.
Providers and their counsel should consider not only whether CMS had a sufficient factual and regulatory basis for revocation, but also whether the procedures afforded before the sanctions took effect satisfied constitutional due process requirements.
Providers who receive a Medicare revocation notice should act promptly to protect their rights. The administrative appeal deadlines remain critically important, and Lee v. Kennedy does not eliminate the need to pursue reconsideration or other available administrative remedies. Providers should also carefully evaluate and document the immediate consequences of the revocation, including potential employment termination, contractual restrictions, loss of reimbursement, and other professional harm.
Where a revocation threatens serious and potentially irreversible consequences before an evidentiary hearing can occur, there may be grounds to evaluate a separate constitutional challenge. Importantly, the availability and viability of such a challenge will depend on the specific facts and circumstances of the case.
Although Lee v. Kennedy does not establish a right to a pre-deprivation hearing, it opens a potentially important avenue for providers to challenge the constitutionality of Medicare revocation procedures before completing lengthy administrative appeals. The central question remains whether CMS can impose sanctions that effectively end a provider’s career before providing a meaningful opportunity to be heard. The district court’s consideration of that question on remand will be worth watching.
Healthcare providers facing Medicare revocation should carefully evaluate both the grounds for CMS’s determination and the procedures used to impose the sanctions. As Lee v. Kennedy illustrates, the consequences of losing Medicare billing privileges can extend well beyond the Medicare program, potentially affecting employment, professional relationships, and a provider’s ability to continue practicing. Chapman Law Group represents physicians and other healthcare providers in Medicare revocation appeals, administrative proceedings, and related regulatory matters. If you’re a provider who received a revocation notice or is facing a lengthy re-enrollment consult one of our experienced legal counsel who specializes in healthcare law to evaluate potential available remedies, protect your rights, and determine whether the circumstances warrant a separate constitutional challenge.
Contact us HERE
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) may revoke a provider’s Medicare billing privileges for several reasons, including failure to comply with Medicare enrollment requirements, submission of false or misleading information, certain felony convictions, abuse of billing privileges, or improper affiliations with other healthcare providers. Under 42 C.F.R. § 424.535(a)(19), CMS may also revoke Medicare enrollment when it determines that a provider’s affiliation with another individual or organization poses an undue risk of fraud, waste, or abuse. Importantly, an affiliation-based revocation does not necessarily require a finding that the affected provider personally engaged in fraudulent billing or other misconduct.
A Medicare revocation hearing allows a provider to challenge CMS’s determination before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ). Generally, the provider must first request reconsideration of the revocation through the administrative appeals process. If CMS upholds its decision, the provider may request an ALJ hearing, where evidence and legal arguments concerning the revocation may be presented. For attorneys representing providers in these proceedings, like those at Chapman Law Group who specialize in healthcare law, an important consideration is whether the evidence supports the specific regulatory grounds cited by CMS. Unlike the initial paper-based reconsideration process, an ALJ proceeding can provide an opportunity for testimony and a more formal examination of the evidence.
The CMS Preclusion List identifies healthcare providers and prescribers who are prohibited from receiving payment for certain services furnished to Medicare Advantage beneficiaries or drugs prescribed under Medicare Part D. Providers may be placed on the list following Medicare revocation and an active re-enrollment bar when CMS determines that the underlying conduct is detrimental to the Medicare program. Certain other conduct or felony convictions may also result in preclusion. Placement on the list can have substantial consequences for a provider’s employment, prescribing activities, and ability to participate in Medicare-related healthcare arrangements.
Healthcare providers seeking to restore revoked Medicare billing privileges generally must challenge the revocation through the applicable administrative appeals process or satisfy the conditions for re-enrollment after any applicable enrollment bar expires. A provider may initially request reconsideration, followed by an ALJ hearing and further administrative review if the revocation is upheld. Successfully overturning the revocation may result in restoration of billing privileges, while providers subject to a final revocation and re-enrollment bar may need to submit a new enrollment application once eligible. Because these sanctions can affect a provider’s employment and financial stability long before an appeal is resolved, Chapman Law Group’s representation focuses not only on challenging the underlying revocation but also on addressing its broader professional and regulatory consequences.
There is no single timeframe that applies to every Medicare revocation. Under 42 C.F.R. § 424.535(g), many revocations become effective 30 days after CMS or the designated Medicare contractor mails the revocation notice. However, certain grounds for revocation may result in an earlier effective date, including some adverse legal actions or determinations that a provider is no longer operational. Filing a reconsideration request generally does not automatically suspend the revocation, meaning a provider may lose the ability to bill Medicare while the appeals process remains pending.
The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has jurisdiction over federal judicial districts in Alaska, Arizona, California, Hawaii, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, and Washington, as well as Guam and the Northern Mariana Islands. The court’s decisions are particularly relevant to federal cases arising within those jurisdictions. However, because Lee v. Kennedy was issued as an unpublished, nonprecedential memorandum disposition, its significance as binding authority is limited under Ninth Circuit Rule 36-3.
The likelihood of successfully appealing a Medicare revocation depends on the specific regulatory grounds cited by CMS, the available evidence, and whether the agency properly applied the relevant Medicare enrollment requirements. There is no reliable success rate that can predict the outcome of an individual provider’s appeal. In evaluating these cases, Chapman Law Group considers whether CMS had a sufficient factual and regulatory basis for revocation and whether the provider received the procedural protections required under the circumstances. As Lee v. Kennedy illustrates, certain cases may also raise separate constitutional questions concerning the procedures used to impose sanctions, although such claims do not necessarily determine whether the underlying revocation was proper.
In Lee v. Kennedy, No. 26-1820 (9th Cir. Sept. 15, 2026), the Ninth Circuit reversed a district court’s dismissal of Dr. Mansur Lee’s constitutional due process claim arising from the revocation of his Medicare billing privileges. CMS had imposed a 10-year re-enrollment bar and placed Dr. Lee on the CMS Preclusion List based on his affiliation with a hospice whose billing privileges had also been revoked. The court concluded that his claim concerning the absence of a hearing before the sanctions took effect could proceed in federal district court without first exhausting the administrative appeals process. However, the court did not determine whether CMS had actually violated his constitutional rights or whether the revocation itself was improper.
In certain circumstances, yes. Although healthcare providers generally must exhaust available administrative remedies before seeking judicial review of a Medicare revocation, the Ninth Circuit recognized an important distinction in Lee v. Kennedy. The court determined that Dr. Lee could pursue his separate constitutional claim concerning the lack of a pre-deprivation hearing without completing the administrative appeals process. For healthcare providers and attorneys like those at Chapman Law Group who specialize in issues involving CMS, this raises two potentially distinct legal questions: whether CMS had sufficient grounds to revoke Medicare billing privileges, and whether the procedures used to impose those sanctions satisfied constitutional due process requirements. The decision does not mean every provider can bypass administrative review simply by alleging a constitutional violation. The nature of the claim, the harm suffered, and the purpose of further administrative proceedings remain important considerations.
Under the current Medicare administrative appeals process, CMS generally does not provide an evidentiary hearing before revoking a provider’s billing privileges. Instead, providers receive a revocation notice and may challenge the determination through reconsideration and subsequent administrative proceedings. Whether the Constitution requires additional procedural protections before certain sanctions take effect remains an unresolved question. In Lee v. Kennedy, the Ninth Circuit allowed a physician to pursue that constitutional challenge in federal court, but it did not establish a general right to a hearing before every Medicare revocation.
"*" indicates required fields
Laith Quasem
Associate Attorney
Professional Licensing & Regulatory Affairs, Healthcare Compliance, Federal Criminal Defense
Seattle Office
5306 Ballard Ave NW, Suite 310
Seattle, WA 98107
Phone: (877) 234-5911
Laith Quasem, addresses a risk that is often a routine decision: opening a patient’s electronic medical record without a legitimate reason….
Attorney Laith Quasem of Chapman Law Group was recently featured in a Stateline article examining the federal government’s expanding efforts to combat Medicaid fraud across all 50 states.
A Washington State dentist had been placed on the Washington Medicaid Provider Termination and Exclusion List following a prior criminal……
When a Michigan DME company’s Medicare supplier number was revoked with multiple allegations, our compliance attorneys got it reinstated.
Our healthcare compliance attorneys got a physician’s Medicare enrollment and billing privileges restored, after requests for medical records unknowingly went unheeded.